Is Apple proper?

It is not clean why Apple might worry about the specially created software being stolen or misused, for the reason that work might take location in Apple's labs and would presumably be no greater problem to robbery than any other Apple software. Apple is thought for its strong security and there are not any known incidents of its supply code or cryptographic keys being stolen.

further, the same approach could no longer paintings on gadgets released after the 5c because they're geared up with a chip called "comfy Enclave," which helps encrypt data using each the password and a unique user identification this is provisioned throughout manufacturing and not acknowledged to Apple.

the larger difficulty is the precedent. If Apple complied, it'd mark the first time a software corporation created a device to break into its own products in response to an order from regulation enforcement. era businesses and privacy advocates fear an limitless circulate of comparable requests - no longer simply from the U.S. 

government, however additionally from foreign governments or even litigants in civil cases. Technologists are horrified with the aid of the very concept of intentionally creating software that undermines security.